Follow us

The longest day of your life: deciding whether to enter a plea

Take a look at this article: Man gets 40 years in jail after rejecting plea deal that would have freed him immediately.

Look at this man… Look at his eyes. He could have pled to time-served and gone home, “hence without day” as they say. Instead, he went to trial…

…and was convicted…

… and got 40 years. In prison. The pen. The big house. That’s a life sentence, folks.

When you enter a plea, you’re asking for mercy… If you go to trial, you may be asking for justice. At least, that’s what an old trial judge, J. Rogers Padgett of Tampa, used to say. That guy is a wealth of courtroom wisdom.

Making the decision as to how to resolve a case is hard. No one wants go to jail or prison. Well, most normal people don’t – some would rather do that than serve probation, for various reasons. How does one ever decide to voluntarily agree to go to prison?

My suggestions to clients are:

  1. Know what the worst-case scenario is (what’s the maximum sentence possible?).
  2. Know what your judge does in cases like yours. If everyone similarly situated to you gets ____, then more than likely you’ll get that, too.
  3. Look objectively at your case. If you did not commit the crime, or the government can’t prove it, absolutely consider going to trial with a great trial lawyer. If you have some liability, be realistic about it and think about how to lessen the impact of a sentence. Remember, there are lots of people in prison on principle – the ones that relied on a false sense of something or other while not being real about their situation. And finally….
  4. Think about this: if you reject the plea, and get a harsher sentence – what would the longest day of your life beUpon going to jail or prison, what would the longest day of your life be while incarcerated??

Call for a consultation, come in and talk, and if you haven’t figured it out, I’ll tell you. No one ever guesses correctly, and are surprised when I tell them. Trust me, it will make a difference in your plea-vs-trial decision making.

Look at the man in the photo…look at his eyes. He has figured out the answer to my question.

Onward justice!